Directions from US-22 and PA-655 (Big Valley Pike), Mill Creek, PA: Turn onto the PA-655 N (Big Valley Pike for 9.5 mi; cemetery will be on the left next to the church 200 W Main St Allensville PA
| No | Lastname | First,Middle,Maiden Names | Birth | Death | Plot | Inscriptions | Notes |
| 1 | Decker  | Sarah C. Orlady | __/__/__ | 09/08/1859 | | | w/o Nicholas G., aged 52yrs 4m |
| 2 | Focht  | Merton D. | __/__/1900 | __/__/1983 | | | cousin |
| 3 | Hazlett  | Goldie D. | 09/26/1915 | 10/20/2010 | | | Parents of Joan Marie, Mary Ellen, H. Gary, and Carol J |
| 4 | Hazlett  | H. Gary | 11/28/1943 | 12/28/2002 | | | |
| 5 | Hazlett  | Herbert F. | 10/27/1910 | 08/21/1999 | | | Parents of Joan Marie, Mary Ellen, H. Gary, and Carol J |
| 6 | Metz  | Anne M. | 08/09/1917 | 05/13/2006 | | | |
| 7 | Metz  | Frances M. | __/__/1920 | __/__/2010 | | | Mother, Parents of Robert B., Garry A., Dennis F., and James R |
| 8 | Metz  | Helen C. | 07/01/1914 | 02/17/2000 | | | |
| 9 | Metz  | Ralph T. | 12/23/1917 | 04/27/2003 | | | |
| 10 | Metz  | Roy B. Jr. | __/__/1919 | __/__/1983 | | | Father, Parents of Robert B., Garry A., Dennis F., and James R |
| 11 | Musser  | Albert J. | __/__/1874 | __/__/1942 | | | |
| 12 | Musser  | Jacob L. | __/__/1877 | __/__/1956 | | | |
| 13 | Musser  | M. Elizabeth | __/__/1883 | __/__/1955 | | | |
| 14 | Musser  | Samuel R. | __/__/1886 | __/__/1967 | | | |
| 15 | Musser  | W. Frank | __/__/1888 | __/__/1956 | | | |
| 16 | Orlady  | Eleanor | 01/22/1799 | 05/07/1883 | | | w/o Paul |
| 17 | Orlady  | Henry | __/__/__ | 01/08/1840 | | | 84 yrs, Revolutionary War Veteran |
| 18 | Orlady  | Infant | __/__/__ | 09/12/1851 | | | s/o Samuel and Mary G., aged 2m 10d |
| 19 | Orlady  | Kezia Jane | __/__/__ | 07/01/1851 | | | d/o Paul and Eleanor, 22yrs 1m |
| 20 | Orlady  | Mary G. | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | w/o Samuel |
| 21 | Orlady  | Paul | __/__/__ | 01/23/1857 | | | 70yrs 1m 16d |
| 22 | Orlady  | Samuel | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | |
| 23 | Orlady  | Sarah E. | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | |
| 24 | Sheets  | James P. | 09/24/1932 | 09/22/1980 | | | |
| 25 | Smith  | Donald L. | __/__/1921 | __/__/1974 | | | |
| 26 | Smith  | Donna M. | __/__/__ | __/__/1963 | | | |
| 27 | Smith  | Goldie M. | __/__/1928 | __/__/2000 | | | |
| 28 | Weaver  | Florence Metz | 09/25/1908 | 09/18/1989 | | | |