Directions from the intersection of Kistler Rd and US 522, Mt Union, PA: Head north on US-522 N/Croghan Pike for 0.8 mi; Turn right onto US-22 E/US-522 N for 0.7 mi; Turn right onto Newton Rd 1.8 mi; Continue onto Wayne St for 364 ft; Turn right onto Church St for 0.1 mi; cemetery is on the right.
| No | Lastname | First,Middle,Maiden Names | Birth | Death | Plot | Inscriptions | Notes |
| 1 | Barben  | Alex | 02/12/1824 | 09/02/1903 | | | |
| 2 | Barben | Susanna | 10/03/1827 | 03/10/1910 | | | w/o Alex |
| 3 | Bower | Annie G. | __/__/__ | 01/22/1904 | | | d/o Charles & Hattie |
| 4 | Bower | Charles | __/__/1816 | __/__/1867 | | | Mexican War, Lieut., Co M. 2nd Pa Militia |
| 5 | Bower | Charles C. | __/__/__ | __/__/1840 | | | s/o Dr. Charles, Aged 17y 5m 18d |
| 6 | Bower | Harriet N. | 06/16/1824 | 04/22/1897 | | | w/o Dr. Charles |
| 7 | Cassady | Edward | 08/08/1847 | 06/04/1920 | | | |
| 8 | Cassady | Edward | __/__/__ | 09/12/1882 | | | s/o David & Josephine, Aged 3m 10d |
| 9 | Cassady | Harry | __/__/1882 | __/__/1882 | | | s/o David & Josephine, aged 2y 6d |
| 10 | Cassady | Josephine Barben | __/__/__ | 06/02/1894 | | | w/o David, Aged 45y 5m 7d |
| 11 | Cassady | Nancy J. Barden | 01/02/1849 | 07/17/1908 | | | w/o Edward, Aged 39y ?M 15d |
| 12 | Houck | Hattie C. | 06/18/1839 | __/__/1888 | | | w/o E. C., d/o James Smelker |
| 13 | Houck | Infant | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | |
| 14 | Johnston | Andrew | __/__/1845 | 05/11/1907 | | | Corp, Co I 22 Regt, Pa Vol Cav, Aged 62y 3m |
| 15 | Johnston | Catharine | __/__/1853 | __/__/1932 | | | w/o Andrew |
| 16 | Johnston | David | 01/20/1836 | 03/03/1892 | | | |
| 17 | Johnston | Elizabeth Forgy | __/__/1873 | __/__/1959 | | | wife |
| 18 | Johnston | Elizabeth Stine | __/__/__ | 11/17/1878 | | | w/o Thomas, Aged 71y 7m 17d |
| 19 | Johnston | Ella E. | __/__/1873 | __/__/1938 | | | w/o William |
| 20 | Johnston | H. Irvin | 03/01/1847 | 07/31/1919 | | | |
| 21 | Johnston | Hannah E. | __/__/1901 | __/__/1918 | | | |
| 22 | Johnston | Lillie May | 06/13/1879 | 03/03/1917 | | | w/o Oscar |
| 23 | Johnston | M. Josephine | 04/26/1851 | 08/05/1917 | | | w/o H. Irvin |
| 24 | Johnston | Margaret A. | 07/16/1838 | 11/04/1906 | | | w/o David |
| 25 | Johnston | Oscar A. | 10/07/1877 | 02/12/1951 | | | |
| 26 | Johnston | Robert R. | 11/17/1863 | 04/28/1899 | | | Husband |
| 27 | Johnston | William L. | __/__/1870 | __/__/1919 | | | |
| 28 | Lund | Elizabeth Sunderland | __/__/__ | 04/01/1844 | | | w/o George, Aged 27y 9m 12d |
| 29 | Mcdevitt | Jane | __/__/1845 | __/__/1916 | | | |
| 30 | Norton | Benjamin | __/__/__ | __/__/1879 | | | Aged ?Y 1m 9d |
| 31 | Norton | Charles W. | __/__/1877 | __/__/1952 | | | |
| 32 | Norton | Chloea E. | __/__/1877 | __/__/1945 | | | |
| 33 | Norton | Helen A. | __/__/1926 | __/__/1927 | | | |
| 34 | Norton | Infant | __/__/1940 | __/__/1940 | | | Son |
| 35 | Norton | James B. | __/__/1897 | __/__/1962 | | | |
| 36 | Norton | James P. | __/__/1921 | __/__/1921 | | | |
| 37 | Norton | Lorma J. | __/__/1902 | __/__/1986 | | | |
| 38 | Norton | Ralph H. | __/__/1895 | __/__/1965 | | | Pvt, U.S. Army, Eng, WWI |
| 39 | Rosenberry | Eleanor | __/__/1845 | __/__/1929 | | | |
| 40 | Rosenberry | James | __/__/1841 | __/__/1924 | | | Civil War, Co F 46th Regt P V I |
| 41 | Shade | Benjamin F. | __/__/1843 | __/__/1910 | | | Co F 194th Regt P V |
| 42 | Shade | John | __/__/__ | __/__/1877 | | | Aged 62y ?M 11d |
| 43 | Shade | Salome | __/__/1864 | __/__/1914 | | | w/o B. F. |
| 44 | Stine | Cyrus | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | |
| 45 | Stine | Henrietta Johnston | __/__/__ | __/__/__ | | | |
| 46 | Sunderland | Catherine M. Forgy | 07/12/1906 | 12/14/1944 | | | |
| 47 | Sunderland | Hannah W. | 09/22/1867 | 12/14/1912 | | | w/o James |
| 48 | Sunderland | Helen | 09/07/1903 | 05/29/1915 | | | |
| 49 | Sunderland | James A. | __/__/1870 | __/__/1946 | | | |
| 50 | Sunderland | Marshall Dallas | 05/24/1910 | 05/29/1985 | | | |
| 51 | Sunderland | William H. | __/__/__ | 09/15/1891 | | | Aged 53y 1m 1d |
